44of every 100 new checking accounts opened in 2024 went to digital banks and fintechs
4went to community banks
52went to everyone else

Cornerstone Advisors, Beyond the Paycheck Motel, 2025 research recap, Figure 6. New checking accounts across all ages; community banks defined as institutions under $100 billion in assets.

ArticlesFinancial services

Community Banks Built the Digital Front Door and Still Lost the Younger Customer

Community banks have branches, lenders and local relationships. So why can Chime feel like the more complete bank?

For most of a decade, community banks heard the same prescription. Make account opening digital. Put the bank in the customer’s pocket. Add mobile deposit, card controls, digital wallets, person-to-person payments and a better app, and the trip to the branch stops being a reason to choose someone else.

I ran marketing inside a community bank holding company for most of that decade, and I heard the prescription at every conference and in most vendor decks. I repeated it in a few.

Banks responded with platform contracts, implementation projects and new digital capabilities. But removing a reason to choose someone else does not create a reason to choose you.

Digital banks and fintechs took 44 of every 100 checking accounts opened in 2024. Community banks took 4, by Cornerstone Advisors’ estimate, across all ages.1 Younger customers did go digital: 63% of Gen Z respondents in the American Bankers Association’s 2025 survey used mobile banking most often, and 3% used branches.2

The industry got the channel right. What it missed was the reason for choosing the bank.

A digital front door is not a reason to enter

The industry solved access. Preference is still open.

Digital account opening answered a real question: can I open this account from my phone? A bank that required paperwork, signatures and a branch visit was putting obvious friction between itself and people accustomed to doing things from a screen.

Removing that friction leaves a different question. Why would I open this account from my phone?

A grand bank entrance with its doors standing open and velvet ropes slack. Footprints on the sidewalk walk past the steps.

Those sound similar. Strategically, they are not close. The first question is about access and the second is about preference, and a bank can solve the first without making much progress on the second.

Removing a reason to choose someone else does not create a reason to choose you.

Even Cornerstone, whose research produced the 44% figure, describes the challenge as a product problem that digital investment alone will not solve.1 I would go one step further: a bank can manage every product it offers without ever managing the institution itself as a product.

The 4.8-star trap

Everyone’s app is fine. Fine is where everyone already is.

Ask a community bank executive about the mobile experience and the answer is usually reassuring. The app is pretty good. It has 4.8 stars. I have said that sentence in a boardroom. It was true, and it was beside the point.

95%of consumers rate their bank’s online and mobile experience good, very good or excellent.
ABA and Morning Consult, 2025 Preferred Banking Methods survey, 4,403 U.S. adults.

Both things can be true and still leave the competitive question unanswered. In the ABA survey, nearly everyone rated their bank’s online and mobile experience as good, very good or excellent.2 When nearly everyone’s customers say the same thing, “ours works fine” describes the whole industry.

A five-star review might mean the customer checked a balance, deposited a check and moved $200 without anything breaking. Those are real accomplishments. They are also a long way from evidence that somebody would switch banks to get the experience. App-store ratings can become retention metrics masquerading as competitive metrics.

The benchmarking problem runs deeper than the rating. Inside the bank, the comparison is a checklist: mobile deposit, card controls, digital payments, account opening. Feature parity achieved. But a customer does not limit the comparison to other community banks. Their phone also contains products that make complicated tasks feel simple, explain what happens next and recover gracefully when something goes wrong.

A phone home screen of navy app icons. One pale tile in the middle carries a bank column and four and a half stars.

Your benchmark should not stop at the bank across town. It should include the best financial experience on your customer’s phone. Good enough is a dangerous place to be when the customer knows what excellent feels like.

So, why should I bank with you?

The younger customer is already profitable. The pitch pretends otherwise.

Strip away the campaign and have the conversation with a 25-year-old deciding where to send a paycheck.

BankBecause we’re local.

CustomerOkay. How does that make my life better?

BankBecause we have great service.

CustomerSo does every bank’s advertising.

BankWe can help when you’re ready to buy a home.

CustomerMaybe. Rocket Mortgage will be waiting too.

BankSomeday, if you start a business, you’ll appreciate having a relationship with a local lender.

CustomerI am currently trying to get $2,000 into an emergency fund.

A relationship bank should have something meaningful to offer when the customer has $500, not only when the customer needs $500,000.

I have written every one of the bank’s lines above into a campaign brief. None of those advantages has to be false for the pitch to fail. They are distant. And behind the pitch sits an assumption the bank rarely says out loud: the younger customer is a small balance to tolerate until a mortgage or business loan makes the relationship worth having.

A long desk. At one end a small jar of coins labeled $2,000; at the other, a house key as long as the desk.

What the customer is worth

The public numbers do not support that. The Fed’s Survey of Consumer Finances puts the median transaction account balance for households under 35 at $5,400.3

Community banks earned a 3.81% net interest margin in the second quarter of 2026,4 which makes that balance worth a little over $200 a year in spread before the customer does anything else.

Then the debit card. Banks under $10 billion in assets are exempt from the Durbin interchange cap, and the Fed’s Regulation II data shows exempt issuers earning an average of $0.51 per debit transaction against $0.23 for covered banks.5 At the 34.6 transactions a month PULSE measured for an active debit card,6 that is roughly another $200 a year.

Call it a little over $400 a year from a primary checking account alone, before a single loan. That covers a typical checking acquisition cost of around $350 in the first year.7

So the 25-year-old with $5,400 and a paycheck is profitable now, and profitable at a community bank specifically, because of an exemption the big banks do not have. Lending is upside.

Chime’s partner banks are small enough to have the exemption too, and it is most of how Chime makes money: payments revenue was $430 million of $670 million in the second quarter of 2026. In September, Chime agreed to buy one of those partners, Stride Bank, for $590 million, and said in the same announcement that it will keep the bank’s assets below $10 billion for the foreseeable future.8 Every community bank has the exemption, but few build the product around it.

One primary checking customer, one year

$5,400median transaction balance, under 35
A community bank, under $10B$418
spread $206
interchange $212
$350 to acquire
The same customer at a bank over $10B$301
spread $206
interchange $95
Deposit spread $5,400 x 3.81% net interest margin$206
Interchange, gross 34.6 transactions a month x 12 x $0.51$212
A year of checking, before any loan$418

Against a $350 acquisition cost, that pays back in 11 months.

Run your bank’s numbers

The five fields hold the public figures from the sequence above. Type over any of them and everything below the line recalculates.

Interchange regime

Deposit spread balance x NIM$206
Interchange, gross transactions x 12 x fee$212
A year of checking, before any loan$418
Payback on the acquisition cost11 months
Gross figures, before servicing, fraud and network costs. Switch the interchange regime to see what the same customer is worth at a bank over $10 billion.

The fifteen-year wait

Which makes the standard pitch worse than distant. The median first-time homebuyer is now 40 years old.9

A bank that tells a 25-year-old “we’ll be there when you buy a house” is proposing a fifteen-year wait.

And when that mortgage finally arrives, independent mortgage banks earned $973 per loan on it in the second quarter of 2026.10

Banks are deferring a customer worth $400 a year for fifteen years so they can compete on rate, against Rocket, for a $973 event.

The fifteen-year wait

$6,000 of checkinggross, at $400 a year

$973the mortgage

Median first-time buyer

What the bank has actually measured

Those figures describe a customer the bank keeps. Before calling younger customers unprofitable, a bank should be able to say what it actually measured. Are they receiving their paychecks here, using the debit card and building savings, or did they open accounts that never became part of their financial lives?

Those are different relationships. Putting them in the same age bucket and reporting an average balance cannot tell you whether the problem is the customer, the proposition or the bank’s failure to become useful.

Nor does a disappointing result tell the institution which lever to pull. Would a better direct-deposit transition change the economics? Would a more useful card experience increase activity? Would simpler servicing reduce costs? Those are hypotheses to test. Age, acquisition channel and relationship depth are not interchangeable explanations.

Human judgment and local knowledge still matter. A person who understands the situation and can take responsibility for resolving it is worth something. But that value needs to be visible before a complicated loan application makes the relationship interesting to the institution.

Chime has fewer levers

Fewer capabilities, one experience.

Chime’s offer centers on everyday money: checking, savings, credit-building products, early access to qualifying direct deposits and overdraft features for eligible members. Its checking account leads with no monthly service fee and no minimum balance.8

A full-service community bank has a broader set of capabilities to assemble. Alongside checking and payments, it may offer consumer lending, mortgages, small-business banking, local decision-makers and places where customers can sit down with someone. Commercial relationships and community partnerships add further possibilities.

Having more capabilities does not automatically produce a more compelling experience.

64%of Chime’s revenue in the second quarter of 2026 was payments, most of it debit interchange.
Chime reported results, Q2 2026: $430 million of $670 million.

Chime does not literally have one product. It has multiple accounts, credit products and banking partners; Chime itself is a financial technology company, not a chartered bank. Its banking services are provided by The Bancorp Bank or Stride Bank, and Chime has agreed to acquire Stride, pending regulatory approval, with closing expected in the first half of 2027.8

What differs is the presentation. Checking, cards, savings and credit building sit inside one Chime-branded app.8 To the customer, the promise is a way to manage money, whoever holds the charter.

A community bank can have more to offer and still make the customer do more work to understand how it fits together.

The org chart has become the customer experience.

Walk inside the community bank. Marketing owns the brand, Digital owns the app, Retail owns the branches and Deposit Product owns checking. Cards manages debit; Consumer Lending and Mortgage have their own businesses. Operations handles servicing, IT manages vendors, Finance evaluates pricing and margin, and Risk and Compliance establish the boundaries.

I owned the first of those boxes for eight years. Nothing about the box was wrong. It just could not see the customer whole, and neither could any of the others.

There is nothing wrong with specialization. A complicated financial institution needs it. The problem appears when the organizational model becomes the customer experience.

Digital can deliver a respectable app while Retail provides excellent branch service. Marketing can run an effective campaign, Deposit Product can price competitive checking and Lending can meet its production goals. Every department can be competent, every dashboard can be green, and the customer proposition can still be mediocre.

The customer experiences one bank while the organization manages twelve functions.

Twelve functions, every one on target

What the customer sees

Marketingowns the brandon target
Digitalowns the appon target
Retailowns the brancheson target
Deposit Productowns checkingon target
Cardsmanages debiton target
Consumer Lendingowns loanson target
Mortgageowns mortgageson target
Operationshandles servicingon target
ITmanages vendorson target
Financepricing and marginon target
Risksets the limitson target
Compliancesets the boundarieson target
One long overcoat with a bank crest, many arms doing different things, and twelve pairs of legs in twelve kinds of shoes beneath the hem.

One bank on the outside. Twelve departments inside, each walking its own way.

The comparison with Chime is whether the features add up to one recognizable promise. A bank with dozens of levers has no advantage if nobody can pull them together.

Everyone can hit their goals and the bank can still lose

A third of new accounts leave inside a year, and no department’s number moves.

Once you see the problem this way, good enough becomes understandable. If the app is treated as a servicing channel, uptime, adoption and satisfaction are sensible measures. If checking is a deposit product, balances and cost of funds matter. If Marketing owns acquisition, applications and cost per account matter.

No individual executive needs to be making a bad decision.

34%of activated new checking customers went inactive or left within their first year, by the institutions’ own estimate.
Digital Banking Report for Pinwheel, The Power of Primacy, March 2024.

In March 2024 research published in The Power of Primacy, financial institutions estimated that a third of activated new customers became inactive or churned within their first year. The report also presented an estimated direct-deposit penetration rate of 55%.11 These were institution-reported estimates, not an audit of individual account histories. They are useful here because they distinguish an account opened from a relationship established.

Every department can be competent, every dashboard can be green, and the customer proposition can still be mediocre.

Marketing meets its application target and Digital meets its adoption target while the customers they counted never make the bank part of their everyday financial lives. The departmental scorecards register the symptoms without explaining the cause.

Twelve gauges on a wall, every needle in the green. Below them, an exit door standing open.

Someone needs to ask the larger question: what should banking with us feel like for this customer? The whole bank, start to finish, and every handoff in between.

That is a product-management question, and it does not get answered merely because each product has a manager.

This is why the Gen Z campaign keeps happening

Advertising is the only lever one department can pull alone.

The skateboard is what a structural problem looks like after it has been handed to the one department that can ship something by Friday.

Suppose Marketing does the research properly. YouGov’s U.S. research among employed Gen Z consumers places low or no maintenance fees, security and reliability, and brand trustworthiness among the leading account-selection factors. Digital usability matters too.12 Separate YouGov research found that building an emergency fund was Gen Z’s most frequently cited savings goal.13

That points toward a more useful conversation than how to make an existing checking campaign look younger: simpler pricing, cash-flow support, emergency savings and clearer guidance through everyday financial decisions.

Now build that.

Suddenly the conversation moves past Marketing to fee income and product economics, funds availability and fraud controls, credit policy, core capabilities, vendor contracts, staffing and data. It is about whether a new offer cannibalizes an existing one, who funds the work and who can resolve a disagreement.

That meeting is harder. I have been the marketing executive in it. The advertising budget was mine to move; the fee schedule was not. So the temptation is to return to the lever that moves without changing the rest of the institution: the advertising.

The photography gets younger. The palette gets brighter. Someone wants TikTok. The copy turns conspicuously casual, and a hundred-year-old bank puts on a hoodie and picks up a skateboard.

A century-old neoclassical bank, EST. 1907 on the pediment, wearing a hoodie with the hood pulled over the roof and the drawstrings hanging past the columns. A skateboard leans against the steps.

Age is the wrong diagnosis. A bank should not be embarrassed that it has existed for a century. Longevity signals stability, and stability matters when someone is deciding where to send a paycheck. The problem is confusing looking young with understanding someone who is young.

What if the bank actually used all of its advantages?

The same bank, run as one product.

Imagine the same community bank behaving as a single product.

A 24-year-old moves direct deposit into the bank. The app notices the first paycheck and offers to set aside $25 of it, once, with one tap and no appointment. The customer does not have to discover a separate product or repeat anything the bank already knows.

When money gets tight, the bank says so before the overdraft, on Tuesday, when Friday’s rent will not clear, and offers a small bridge at a stated price. If the customer wants to build credit, the app shows the two products that would do it, what each costs, and what happens next. Routine banking stays digital because routine banking should be easy.

Then something goes wrong. A payment is delayed, fraud appears or a financial decision requires more explanation than a screen can provide. A person enters the experience with the customer’s context intact, takes ownership of the problem and explains what happens next. The bank does not require the customer to start the story again at every handoff.

What the customer gets is continuity: a person with the context, the authority and the obligation to finish the problem, in a branch when that helps.

A few years later there may be a car loan, a house or a business. The bank should still have to earn that business. But it would enter the conversation with a history of being useful, rather than a promise that usefulness begins now.

Local employers, merchants and community relationships strengthen that further when they produce something the customer can feel. That is a bank whose extra capabilities are worth choosing.

Somebody has to own the whole bank

Where to start.

Community banks do not need to copy Chime’s palette, vocabulary or roadmap. The lesson is coherence: product, brand and experience that reinforce each other.

A bank has several ways to do that. Digital provides speed, people provide judgment, lending expands the relationship and local knowledge makes advice more useful. But those capabilities need to feel like parts of one product.

Getting there requires more than a rebrand or a new box on the organizational chart. These are the three decisions I could not make from the marketing seat, and the ones I would ask for first if I were back in it.

  1. Someone owns the proposition. Give a senior leader responsibility for the chosen younger-customer proposition across product, digital, retail and marketing, with the budget and decision rights to resolve tradeoffs. The title matters less than the authority. The work stays within the bank’s risk and compliance framework, but it cannot depend on a committee whose members are accountable only for their own departments.
  2. The scorecard measures the relationship and its economics. Keep uptime and app satisfaction, but stop treating them as sufficient evidence of competitiveness. Track new-to-bank acquisition, direct-deposit activation, meaningful account use and twelve-month retention alongside acquisition cost per activated relationship and contribution by acquisition cohort. Agree on funding, servicing, fraud and acquisition-cost assumptions with Finance, so the number the owner is judged on is one Finance already believes.
  3. Start with one journey. Take the first paycheck arriving in a newly opened account and manage the surrounding experience as a single product for one quarter. Bring the relevant functions together, give the owner authority to decide and test the redesigned journey against a credible baseline. Use the quarter to evaluate execution and early activation, then follow those customers long enough to assess retention and economics. Prove that the bank can behave as one thing in one place before asking it to do so everywhere.

Community banks have built digital front doors. The question now is whether anyone inside the building is responsible for what a 25-year-old finds when they get in.

Looking down a long corridor from the open front door: twelve closed office doors with nameplates, and at the far end an empty chair under a spotlight.
Four of every 100 new checking accounts went to community banks.

About the numbers

Sources sit beside the passages they support, or open beneath them on a phone. Research and product descriptions checked September 22, 2026. The organizational diagnosis, proposed scorecard and customer journey are analysis and recommendations; the cited surveys support the figures, and the conclusions are mine. The one-journey plan in “What if the bank actually used all of its advantages?” is a proposition to design and test, not a claim that every bank already has the necessary capabilities, and the survey findings cited do not make every younger customer identical. The $400-a-year figure is gross: it is spread on the median balance plus interchange at exempt rates, before servicing, fraud and network costs, which vary by bank and which a bank’s own numbers should replace.

Footnotes

  1. Cornerstone Advisors. Beyond the Paycheck Motel: Strategic Imperatives for Community Banking, a recap of 2025 research, pp. 17-18, Figure 6. Reports the 2024 estimates of 44% for digital banks/fintechs and 4% for community banks. These are shares of new checking accounts across age groups, not Gen Z-only figures, Chime market share, primary relationships or profitability. The chart defines community banks as institutions below $100 billion in assets, not by the FDIC’s community-bank definition. Read the Cornerstone report ↩ ↩2

  2. American Bankers Association / Morning Consult. 2025 Preferred Banking Methods. Online survey conducted October 1-6, 2025, with a weighted sample of 4,403 U.S. adults. Supports the Gen Z most-used-channel figures of 63% mobile and 3% branches, and the 95% favorable digital-experience rating. Most-used banking channel is not the same as preferred account-opening channel. The 95% figure is not an app-store rating. Read the ABA findings ↩ ↩2

  3. Federal Reserve Board. 2022 Survey of Consumer Finances, Historic Tables, Table 6, family holdings of financial assets by age of reference person. Median transaction account holdings for families under 35 that hold such an account: $5,400 (mean $20,536). The 2022 survey is the most recent published as of this writing. Transaction accounts include checking, savings, money market and call accounts, so the checking-only balance is lower and the figure here is generous to the bank. SCF index and tables ↩

  4. FDIC. Quarterly Banking Profile, Second Quarter 2026, released August 25, 2026. Community bank net interest margin 3.81%; average yield on earning assets 5.66%; average funding cost 1.85%; industry NIM 3.32%. Applying NIM to a noninterest-bearing checking balance understates its value, since that balance costs the bank close to nothing to fund. Read the QBP ↩

  5. Federal Reserve Board. Regulation II, Average Debit Card Interchange Fee by Payment Card Network, 2024 data, published December 19, 2025. All-network average per transaction: $0.51 for exempt issuers (1.21% of transaction value), $0.23 for covered issuers (0.47%). Interchange is gross revenue; network fees and processing costs come out of it. Fed Regulation II data ↩

  6. PULSE. 2024 Debit Issuer Study (2023 data), as reported by ABA Banking Journal, August 9, 2024. Active cardholders completed 34.6 debit transactions per month, including 30.7 point-of-sale transactions. Not age-specific. ABA Banking Journal summary ↩

  7. Digital Onboarding, via The Financial Brand. May 28, 2021: banks and credit unions invest $350 or more to acquire a single checking account. A 2021 figure. Fintel Connect’s 2025 Cost-Per-Acquisition Benchmarking Guide, as summarized by eMarketer in March 2025, gives a range of $150 to $780 across financial products, not checking alone. Financial Brand article | eMarketer summary ↩

  8. Chime. Official checking-account information and Help Center account descriptions, accessed September 22, 2026. Supports the product descriptions, partner-bank disclosure and app-based account structure. Eligibility, limits, timing and fees vary by feature. Describing Chime as one product is an interpretation of its customer-facing proposition, not a claim that it has one legal account, no internal complexity or no human support. Chime announced a definitive agreement to acquire Stride Bank, N.A. for $590 million in cash on September 8, 2026, subject to OCC and Federal Reserve approval and expected to close in the first half of 2027, and stated it “will manage its balance sheet and keep its assets below $10 billion for the foreseeable future.” The announcement does not mention the Durbin Amendment; the connection to the interchange exemption is analysis, shared by most coverage of the deal. The Q2 2026 figures are from Chime’s results released August 5, 2026 and its Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2026: payments revenue of $430.0 million of $669.8 million total revenue, with interchange on debit card transactions at 39% of revenue and on credit card transactions at 25%. Chime announcement | Q2 2026 results | Form 10-Q | Banking Dive coverage | Checking-account information | Account and card descriptions ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  9. National Association of Realtors. 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers, November 4, 2025. Median age of first-time homebuyers: 40, up from 38 the prior year; first-time buyer share 21%. NAR release ↩

  10. Mortgage Bankers Association. Quarterly Mortgage Bankers Performance Report, Second Quarter 2026, released August 18, 2026. Net production income of $973 per loan (25 basis points) for independent mortgage banks and mortgage subsidiaries of chartered banks; total production revenue 333 basis points. A bank that portfolios the loan earns spread over its life instead, which depends on its funding and credit assumptions. MBA release ↩

  11. Jim Marous / Banking Transformed / Digital Banking Report. The Power of Primacy, March 2024, published with Pinwheel, p. 25, Chart 12, and p. 28, Chart 15. The 34% figure is an institution-reported estimate of activated new customers becoming inactive or churning within a year, not a measured closure rate. The 55% direct-deposit chart is titled for newly acquired customers, but its question refers more broadly to checking customers. Neither figure is Gen Z-specific, and neither establishes lifetime direct-deposit adoption or primary-account status. Read The Power of Primacy ↩

  12. YouGov. Gen Z banking trends: Which banks are making a stronger impression, June 3, 2026. Profiles data collected March 2025-March 2026. Among employed Gen Z consumers, reported account-selection factors include low or no maintenance fees (31%), security and reliability (29%), brand reputation and trustworthiness (26%), and digital usability (21%). These are stated preferences, not causal explanations of provider choice. Read the YouGov account-choice analysis ↩

  13. YouGov. Gen Z’s financial behaviors in 2025, November 18, 2025. Profiles data collected November 2024-November 2025. Building an emergency fund was the most frequently cited savings goal among U.S. Gen Z respondents, at 32%. Read the YouGov financial-behavior analysis ↩

If you want to see this with your organization’s own numbers, book twenty minutes.